The six outcomes, in the Dicastery's own terms, are: nihil obstat, where signs of the Holy Spirit are recognized "in the midst" of the experience and the bishop may promote devotion and pilgrimages; prae oculis habeatur, positive signs mixed with confusion that needs doctrinal clarification; curatur, serious critical elements but widespread fruits, so the bishop does not encourage the phenomenon; sub mandato, problems caused by people misusing an otherwise acceptable devotion; prohibetur et obstruatur, a public prohibition with catechesis explaining it; and declaratio de non supernaturalitate, a finding of fraud, fabrication, or mythomania. Only the Pope can authorize a declaration that something is supernatural, and the norms expect that to be rare.

Medjugorje is the first large case decided this way. On September 19, 2024, the Dicastery granted a nihil obstat to the spiritual experience connected with the reported apparitions, authorizing public devotion while stating that this "does not imply a declaration that they have a direct supernatural origin" and that the faithful are not obliged to believe. Calling Medjugorje "approved apparitions" is therefore wrong; "reported apparitions with a nihil obstat for devotion" is accurate.

The practical effect for pilgrims is small. Lourdes, Fátima, Guadalupe, Knock, and Champion, Wisconsin were recognized under the earlier practice, by a bishop's judgment or by long recognition in the Church's liturgy and by the popes, and that recognition stands. Any new case is judged under the 2024 norms.