The distinction has been stated in every age. The account of Polycarp's martyrdom says Christians worship Christ and love the martyrs as his disciples (quoted in Catechism 957). St. Jerome wrote that we do not worship or adore relics, lest we bow to the creature rather than the Creator. The Council of Trent (1563) and the Second Vatican Council (Sacrosanctum Concilium 111) both affirmed the veneration of authentic relics.

The Church also admits the abuses: forged and traded relics were denounced as early as St. Augustine and helped provoke the Reformation's rejection of the practice. Canon 1190 states that it is absolutely forbidden to sell sacred relics, and the 2017 Instruction asks that relics be honored without superstition. The veneration of relics is a form of popular piety, which the Church approves and regulates; it is not an obligation laid on every Catholic.