St. Faustina's Diary is private revelation. Of private revelations, including those recognized by the authority of the Church, the Catechism (n. 67) says: "They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith." Their role, it continues, is to help the faithful live more fully by Christ's definitive Revelation in a certain period of history. What the Church has done is permit and encourage the devotion, canonize the sister who recorded it, and name a Sunday of the liturgical year for the mercy of God.

The 1978 notification explains that the earlier prohibitions were lifted after original documents unknown in 1959 had been examined, circumstances had changed, and many Polish bishops had given their opinion. St. John Paul II himself said at the canonization that the message "is not a new message": it is the Gospel's own teaching on mercy.